Your Trusted Accident Lawyer with Proven Results! Get a FREE consultation today.
Southerland Law FirmPersonal injury · Brentwood, TN Hurt in a wreck?
Tennessee Injury Data

Data home / Tennessee injury appeals

Tennessee injury appeals · Through September 30, 2026

What are Tennessee appeals courts deciding in injury cases?

Tennessee's Supreme Court and Court of Appeals released 16 decisions in injury cases in the 90 days through September 30, 2026. The most common subject was health care liability (medical malpractice). Each summary links to the full opinion.

Refreshed nightly from Tennessee Supreme Court and Court of Appeals opinions.

Decisions

Karen Byrne v. Flavius Dragila, M.D., et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsSep 30, 2026Knox CountyHealth care liability (medical malpractice)Vacated and remanded

A patient who suffered a serious internal bleed after a hospital stay sued the hospitalist, and the trial court threw the case out as filed too late. The Court of Appeals revived it, finding a real factual dispute about when the patient and her family discovered, or should have discovered, the injury and who was responsible, so the discovery rule question belongs with a factfinder.

Read the opinion · No. E2025-00998-COA-R3-CV

Delester Quarles v. John Doe A, et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsSep 29, 2026Shelby CountyUninsured and underinsured motorist coverageAffirmed

A driver rear-ended by a hit-and-run motorist in Memphis sued the unknown driver and served his own uninsured motorist carrier, but never had summonses issued for the John Doe defendant within the first year. The court held the one-year limitations period against the unknown driver expired, the savings statute could not revive the already-expired claim, and the UM claim was properly dismissed.

Read the opinion · No. W2025-01252-COA-R3-CV

Scott Patrick Werner, et al. v. De'Anthony Melton

Tennessee Court of AppealsSep 9, 2026Shelby CountyDog bitesAffirmed

A dog owned by a professional basketball player bit a property owner in Eads, and the victim obtained a judgment of about $758,000 after the owner never responded to the suit. The Court of Appeals refused to set the judgment aside, finding service at the owner's New Jersey home on a household member was valid and that his nine-month delay in seeking relief was unreasonable.

Read the opinion · No. W2025-00779-COA-R3-CV

Robert Brock et al. v. Grace Wessel

Tennessee Court of AppealsSep 2, 2026Knox CountyCar and motor vehicle crashesAffirmed

Two people injured in a car collision won default judgments of $25,000 each in general sessions court, but that court set the judgments aside on its own two days later. The Court of Appeals held a general sessions court may do that, so there was no final judgment to appeal and the circuit court correctly sent the case back for trial on the merits.

Read the opinion · No. E2025-00109-COA-R3-CV

Jonathan Crawley v. Zanies Real Estate, LLC et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 28, 2026Davidson CountyPremises liability (slip, trip and fall)Affirmed

A comedy club patron claimed food he was required to buy made him sick. The court upheld judgment for the club because he offered no expert proof that the food more likely than not caused his illness, and the club showed many other diners ate the same dish without problems. Memorandum opinion.

Read the opinion · No. M2024-01014-COA-R3-CV

Michael Dinovo, Jr. et al. v. Kenneth Binkley et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 27, 2026Davidson CountyWorkplace injuriesAffirmed

A worker hurt in a biodiesel plant explosion settled a workers' compensation claim as an employee, then sued claiming he was tricked into that status. The court upheld summary judgment because he had no proof anyone made a false statement to him or that he relied on one, and the approved settlement barred relitigating his employee status.

Read the opinion · No. M2023-00345-COA-R3-CV

Melanie Pleasant v. City of Elizabethton

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 27, 2026Carter CountyClaims against government (GTLA)Affirmed

A woman tripped on a raised lip between sidewalk slabs and sued the city under the Governmental Tort Liability Act. The court held her complaint failed because it never alleged a city employee acted within the scope of employment, the late request to amend was properly denied, and she had no proof the city knew or should have known about the defect.

Read the opinion · No. E2025-01067-COA-R3-CV

Bradley Dyer v. Hudson Haven

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 21, 2026Rutherford CountyUninsured and underinsured motorist coverageReversed and remanded

A driver rear-ended in Smyrna by an uninsured motorist sued the driver and his own UM carrier but never served the at-fault driver, and the carrier defended for 18 months before discovering the gap. The Court of Appeals held the trial court wrongly found excusable neglect in extending the time for service, so the carrier's motion to dismiss should have been granted.

Read the opinion · No. M2024-01364-COA-R9-CV

Angela Johnson et al. v. Shelby County Healthcare Corporation d/b/a Regional One Health et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 18, 2026Shelby CountyWrongful deathAppeal dismissed

A self-represented daughter sued a hospital and doctors over her father's death, but the trial court dismissed the case for no certificate of good faith, defective pre-suit notice, and the statute of limitations. The Court of Appeals dismissed her appeal because her brief badly failed the appellate rules, including reliance on AI-generated and out-of-state law, so the dismissal stands. Memorandum opinion.

Read the opinion · No. W2025-00415-COA-R3-CV

Jon Engle v. Aaron Payne, DDS

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 17, 2026Rutherford CountyHealth care liability (medical malpractice)Affirmed

A patient claimed his dentist missed a cavity on an x-ray, leading to an extraction, bone grafts and implants. The court held the Health Care Liability Act applied, reading x-rays requires expert proof so the common knowledge exception did not fit, and his failure to file a certificate of good faith required dismissal with prejudice.

Read the opinion · No. M2024-01325-COA-R3-CV

Kalyn Doxley, et al. v. Clarence L. Buzz Nabers, Jr., DDS, et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsAug 14, 2026Knox CountyHealth care liability (medical malpractice)Vacated and remanded

After a dentist warned thousands of patients about a remote infection risk from sterilization practices, a patient sought to represent a class of about 8,000. The court vacated class certification, holding the health care liability pre-suit notice rules are substantive and make a class action unavailable here, and that the certification analysis was inadequate in any event.

Read the opinion · No. E2025-01016-COA-R3-CV

Collier ex rel. Chayce C. v. Roussis

Tennessee Supreme CourtJul 31, 2026Knox CountyHealth care liability (medical malpractice)Vacated and remanded

In a birth injury case that ended in a defense verdict, a juror looked up an EpiPen warning label at home and shared it during deliberations. The Supreme Court adopted a new test: once a party shows the jury saw material outside information, prejudice is presumed and the verdict's defender must show no reasonable possibility it changed the result. The case went back to the trial court to apply that test.

Read the opinion · No. E2022-00636-SC-R11-CV

Bennett v. Diversicare Leasing Corporation et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsJul 28, 2026Rutherford CountyHealth care liability (medical malpractice)Reversed and remanded

A dental malpractice plaintiff added an informed consent claim without filing a new certificate of good faith, and the trial court dismissed the amended complaint. The Court of Appeals held counsel's reasonable mistake about unsettled law could be good cause, so the trial court must allow extra time to file the certificate. Memorandum opinion.

Read the opinion · No. M2024-01035-COA-R3-CV

Woodruff v. Ford Motor Co. (Ford appeal)

Tennessee Supreme CourtJul 21, 2026Knox CountyDefective productsReversed and remanded

In the companion appeal from the same fatal crash, the Supreme Court held that Coffman does not require dismissal of the failure-to-warn claim against Ford over its seatbelt extender, since the claim rests on foreseeable misuse of Ford's own product. The court left for trial whether Ford actually had a duty to warn and whether its warnings were adequate.

Read the opinion · No. E2023-00889-SC-R11-CV

Woodruff ex rel. Woodruff v. Ford Motor Co. (Dorel appeal)

Tennessee Supreme CourtJul 21, 2026Knox CountyDefective productsReversed and remanded

A father died and his young son was badly hurt in a Knoxville crash while the boy rode in a booster seat secured with a separately purchased seatbelt extender. The Supreme Court held its 2021 Coffman decision does not automatically bar a failure-to-warn claim against the booster seat maker where two sound products used together allegedly created the danger, and sent the case back for the remaining issues.

Read the opinion · No. E2023-00488-SC-R11-CV

Pamela Salas v. John David Rosdeutscher, M.D. et al.

Tennessee Court of AppealsJul 16, 2026Davidson CountyHealth care liability (medical malpractice)Reversed and remanded

A medical malpractice plaintiff voluntarily dismissed her case and refiled more than a year later, relying on a later sanctions order as the start of the one-year savings period. The court held the savings statute runs from entry of the voluntary dismissal order, so the refiled suit was untimely and must be dismissed.

Read the opinion · No. M2025-00244-COA-R9-CV

Methods and sources

Opinions come from the Tennessee Supreme Court and Court of Appeals as collected by CourtListener, a free archive run by the nonprofit Free Law Project. Each night the newest opinions are checked for injury subjects such as car and truck crashes, premises liability, health care liability and claims against government.

Summaries are written in plain English from the opinion, or taken from the court's own summary paragraph. They describe what the court decided, not legal advice for any other case. Some Court of Appeals opinions are memorandum opinions, which cannot be cited as precedent in unrelated cases.

Always read the full opinion. A decision can be appealed further or later reversed.

Sources: CourtListener (Free Law Project); Tennessee Administrative Office of the Courts. Refreshed nightly. Get this data (CSV).

Ask about this data

Type or speak a question: a ZIP code, road, county, month, bill or car maker. Answers come straight from this site's numbers.

Answers are looked up from the site's own government data, rebuilt every night. No AI writes them. This is not legal advice. Please don't include names or details about your own accident. Questions are not stored. Voice uses your browser's speech recognition. To talk with a lawyer, call (615) 767-2271.

Common questions

Answered from the latest data each night.

How many injury cases have Tennessee appeals courts decided recently?

Tennessee's Supreme Court and Court of Appeals released 16 decisions in injury cases in the 90 days through September 30, 2026. The most common subject on this page is health care liability (medical malpractice).

What is the latest Tennessee injury appeal decision?

Karen Byrne v. Flavius Dragila, M.D., et al., decided by the Tennessee Court of Appeals on September 30, 2026 (from Knox County). Outcome: vacated and remanded. A patient who suffered a serious internal bleed after a hospital stay sued the hospitalist, and the trial court threw the case out as filed too late.

What have Tennessee courts decided recently about health care liability (medical malpractice)?

This page has 6 recent decisions on health care liability (medical malpractice). The newest is Karen Byrne v. Flavius Dragila, M.D., et al. (September 30, 2026), vacated and remanded.

What have Tennessee courts decided recently about uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage?

This page has 2 recent decisions on uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. The newest is Delester Quarles v. John Doe A, et al. (September 29, 2026), affirmed.

What have Tennessee courts decided recently about defective products?

This page has 2 recent decisions on defective products. The newest is Woodruff v. Ford Motor Co. (Ford appeal) (July 21, 2026), reversed and remanded.

Where do these appeals decisions come from?

Opinions released by the Tennessee Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, found through CourtListener (Free Law Project) and checked each night. Each summary is plain English and links to the full opinion. A summary is not legal advice about any case.

Wes Southerland

Hurt in a crash in Middle Tennessee?

Tennessee gives most injured people one year from the date of the injury to file a claim. Talk with Wes Southerland about your options. You pay nothing unless we win your case.

Call or text (615) 767-2271
CallText